|
Review
by
Kevin Ma: |
Director Kon Ichikawa's
classic 1959 war drama Fire on the Plains and
its source novel by Shohei Ooka portray starving Japanese
soldiers in New Guinea resorting to cannibalism at
the end of World War II. While the novel was part
fictional, the truth about cannibalism in New Guinea
gets its time of day in the 1987 documentary The
Emperor's Naked Army Marches On, a gripping film
that proves truth is sometimes really stranger than
fiction. Directed by Kazuo Hara, the film offers an
intensely fascinating subject in the form of Kenzo
Okuzaki, a World War II veteran who already had quite
a past before filming: he served 13 years in prison
for killing a real estate agent in the 1950s, then
he was sent to jail on several other occasions for
slinging steel marbles at the Emperor, passing out
pornographic handbills featuring the Emperor, and
for plotting to kill the Japanese Prime Minister.
This is the type of man that has to inform the police
just to leave his city of residency.
Filmed between 1982 and 1987,
the film chronicles Okuzaki traveling around Japan
to investigate the truth behind the execution of two
soldiers that occurred 23 days after the war had ended.
Driving around a wagon that has a huge sign on the
top with written derogatory messages against the Emperor
and the Prime Minister, Okuzaki spends most of the
film tracking fellow soldiers down one by one to interview
them about the executions. From then on, the film
becomes a series of prolonged interviews where the
officers beat around the bush to avoid telling the
truth ("Why would you want to disturb the dead by
bringing it up?" one officer asks angrily.). However,
Okuzaki uses persistence and incoherent interrogation
methods, which sometimes even include violence and
confinement, to break them down. Of course, he knows
he's crazy; he even volunteers to call the police
on the interviewees' behalf. But that doesn't stop
his insistence in getting the truth. Even when the
family members of the deceased decide to stop accompanying
Okuzaki, he simply uses his friends and his wife to
impersonate them so he can continue playing the sympathy
card.
The most impressive aspect
of The Emperor's Naked Army Marches On is Hara's
methods. While the film's production values are simple
(the boom mic is visible in several instances), Hara
keeps his camera at the distance of a spectator. Even
when Okuzaki pins an old man to the ground and starts
punching him, Hara simply stands outside, refusing
to get involved while the poor man's wife can only
grab Okuzaki's arm while saying "no violence". While
Hara later admitted that he strongly disliked Okuzaki
by the time filming had ended, the film's tone is
surprisingly balanced. As a result, Okuzaki's image
is rather bipolar. His insistence in getting the truth
behind the possible wrongful executions to console
his dead comrades' souls is admirable. On the other
hand, early scenes of him driving around the Imperial
Palace in his wagon and confronting the numerous police
officers show that he might not be the most mentally
balanced veteran in Japan. No matter how you may see
Okuzaki, the film is more interesting due to its central
character.
When Okuzaki eventually gets
his old military officers to tell what may be the
truth, the details of cannibalism in New Guinea are
often disturbing. On the other hand, it's these first-person
accounts of the war atrocities that make The Emperor
such a compelling film. Sixty years after the end
of World War II, first-person accounts from veterans
are getting increasingly harder to come by. With the
ongoing controversies surrounding Japanese history's
view of the war, Hara's film remains surprisingly
timely 20 years after its release. Even if the interviewer
is a hostile and incoherent 60-year-old man, the value
of the footage and its impact cannot be denied. By
the time the film reaches a tragic conclusion so absurd
that it borders on being darkly comedic, you may realize
that The Emperor's Naked Army Marches On is
not a film you can easily forget. (Kevin Ma 2007)
|
|